Sonny McKinley Talks with Captain Jack

Sonny is a girl who truly lives up to her name. She has a sunny personality and has an easy laugh. She’s wanted to get into the industry from a young age and is very comfortable being naked around strangers. With a body like that, it’s understandable! Sonny was very fun to talk to and I hope you enjoy this interview!

Sonny McKinley

Captain Jack: Tell me about Sonny Mckinley.

Sonny McKinley: I am from New Jersey originally, born and bred. I moved to Los Angeles about 5 years ago. I was a musical theatre kid and I feel the theatre to porn pipeline is alive and well. I think at a pretty young age in high school I was aware that sex work was something I wanted to do. I knew that I wanted to be a stripper, I love to dance, I love theatre, I love being on stage. And I thought, ‘I don’t really see what’s wrong with this. This would be something that I really enjoy!’ So, it’s something that I knew I wanted to try at a pretty young age. And by the time I did get into it, I loved it, I was really happy with it. I was a stripper in New Jersey for four years then a friend of mine got a scholarship to UCLA. He asked me to move out here with him and I wanted to try something new and see what was out there! So, I moved to LA and eventually got into porn.

CJ: How old are you?

Sonny: I’m 25.

CJ: How long have you been shooting now?

Sonny: I’ve been shooting for about a year now.

CJ: You have some nice breasts, what size are they?

Sonny: Oh, thank you. I appreciate that. It depends on who’s measuring them but I would say about a 36 C.

CJ: Were you a very sexual person before you entered the industry?

Sonny: Yes. (laughs) Emphatically so. (laughs) I was an intensely sexual and sensual human being but I didn’t have the lexicon to describe the fact that it was true. So, even though it was true, I don’t necessarily know if I had the awareness of it until I got into sex work and had the benefit of hindsight.

Sonny McKinley

CJ: Were you with girls before porn?

Sonny: Yes but it took me a long time to grow the “balls” to do so. (laughs) I remember being in high school and knowing that I was interested in girls as well as guys. I was raised very Catholic so a very small part of me still believed that there might be some sort of divine consequence if I ever kissed a girl or asked her out and I was always afraid to. So, I didn’t end up having experiences with women until I was 19 but I knew much earlier than that that I wanted to.

CJ: Do you have a count of how many people you were with before porn?

Sonny: Oh my goodness! I love these questions! (laughs) I have a vague estimate of how many people I possibly might have slept with before porn and I want to say it’s 200, give or take.

CJ: Doing the quick math, you started stripping right when you turned 18?

Sonny: Yes.

CJ: The first time you got up on stage taking off your clothes in front of all these older men, how did you handle that?

Sonny: I couldn’t tell you why I’m so comfortable being naked around people. It wasn’t a big deal as far as feeling uncomfortable. I think the biggest learning curve when I started stripping was that I didn’t know how to pole dance yet. That was the hardest part for me; learning how to pole dance and talking to other girls and learning how to do tricks. The getting naked part was really fun right off the bat. I loved it. It was wonderful.

CJ: Why did you start doing OnlyFans?

Sonny: I was stripping for a long time and I still do actually. I love doing it. But during Covid, 15 days quickly spread into 15 months. And because all of the work I had ever done was in person and that’s the only job that I had from being 18 into my adulthood, I was pretty shaken. I started webcamming a couple of months in and then I met some friends who manage the OnlyFans of other girls in the industry who had experience shooting mainstream. They asked if I would shoot content and I said, ‘Absolutely!’ At the time, I didn’t have a public persona, I didn’t have an Instagram, I didn’t network with anybody, nobody knew me. I didn’t mind telling people, all my friends knew but the public didn’t. I had to get comfortable committing to ‘this is what I’m doing with my future’ and I wanted everybody else to know. And then it progressed from there.

Sonny McKinley

CJ: How did you come up with your stage name?

Sonny: I really like being ‘Sonny’ and my mom called me sunshine when I was younger so I thought it would be cute to play on that. Then, I went on a random name generator and looked for last names and I just found one that I liked.

CJ: You described your first time stripping, what about when you were on a professional porn set? Were you intimidated? Nervous? Turned on? How’d that first scene go?

Sonny: Wonderful! (laughs) It was so good!

CJ: Who was your first scene for?

Sonny: My first boy/girl scene was for Naughty America and my partner was Kyle Mason. It was such a blessing. I was shocked. I had never in person seen a dick that big! Ever! I never touched one, I had never been in a room with one. I was, ‘Oh my God! That’s mine! That’s for me today!’ (laughs) Which was super exciting.

CJ: That was your first boy/girl scene. How about your first girl/girl scene?

Sonny: I shot a few scenes with a company called She Seduced Me even before signing with an agency. I got to work with Alan and he’s wonderful. I was really new and I was a lot more nervous for those because I had never been on a porn set before. I was nevous about am I angling the camera, are the stills going to come out ok, is this an appropriate way to interact with someone on a porn set…so there was a learning curve there but once I got comfortable, I love Alan, I love She Seduced Me, I love doing girl/girl, it just took me a while to not be nervous about messing something up.

CJ: What’s your favorite position?

Sonny: That’s really hard. I want to say spoon.

CJ: A lot of the guys in porn are older. Does it ever bother you to work with older men?

Sonny: No, not at all!

CJ: What’s the oldest guy you’ve been with off-camera?

Sonny: I want to say 55.

Sonny McKinley

CJ: Is there a story?

Sonny: I used to spend a lot of time with swingers and some of these people were married. They wanted to try something new so I got to experience having sex with married couples and people who were older than me and things like that. It was very helpful, I think, because they had so much time to figure out what they like and how to do things.

CJ: What do you like sexually? What gets Sonny wet?

Sonny: Oh goodness! I’m a huge romantic. (laughs) I love a nice romantic conversation, lots of eye contract, deep kissing. If I feel wanted, I’m horny and that’s the end of it. (laughs)

CJ: Are you submissive or dominant?

Sonny: I consider myself to be a true switch and I know everyone says that when they’re really a bottom but hear me out! I would say that I have very submissive tendencies and I enjoy being a submissive but if I’m with a partner who also really enjoys being a submissive, making them happy makes me feel so fulfilled. And, so, I’m comfortable in both roles but I would say that I probably lean a little bit more towards being a submissive.

CJ: How often do you masturbate?

Sonny: Probably 5 times a week, maybe 6.

CJ: Favorite method?

Sonny: Hitachi. I like some dildos too.

CJ: Did you watch porn before you got into the industry?

Sonny: Yes I did.

CJ: What was your favorite genre?

Sonny: I really love BDSM porn. That is exclusively what I watched for the first couple of years because I was so into it.

CJ: Did you have any favorite stars?

Sonny: I had a couple that I was enamored with that I got to meet which was so wild. Penelope Kay is somebody that I love so much and I got to work with her for Naughty America and I was, ‘I’m going to cry!’ Katie Kush and Ivy Wolfe are a couple more women that I think are stunning.

Sonny McKinley

CJ: When a guy pops, where do you prefer it?

Sonny: I really like cremapies but I’m not on birth control.

CJ: Are you a swallower?

Sonny: I’m a swallower if you have good hygiene.

CJ: Are you a size queen? Do you like huge cocks?

Sonny: I love huge cocks, they get me off. But if I have feelings for someone and they’re not packing a huge cock, I’m also really happy having sex with them.

CJ: Are you going to do anal on camera?

Sonny: Yes, I am!

CJ: Sounds like something is in the works!

Sonny: Yes. (laughs)

CJ: When was your first anal experience?

Sonny: I have never had a penis in my ass in my whole life.

CJ: Are you training?

Sonny: I am. I am getting ready. I’ve had things in my butt but I’ve never had a man’s whole penis in my butt. And I know that I do enjoy it so I’m just getting ready to take some of the cocks that I should be prepared to take at some point.

CJ: Do you have any fantasies you would like to live out on camera?

Sonny: I have never shot a boy/boy/girl before and I would really like to do that.

CJ: Have you ever done that in your real life?

Sonny: Yes I have.

Sonny McKinley

CJ: What do you look for in a guy off-camera?

Sonny: I like people who are intuitive and maybe a little awkward and sensitive. I also like people who are good conversationalists; people who listen.

CJ: What about girls?

Sonny: Mommy. (laughs) I like big domme vibes. She’s in control, she’s in charge.

CJ: What are you like off-camera? When you have free time, what do you do for fun?

Sonny: I like going on runs. I like to read poetry. I like to cook dinner for my friends.

CJ: What kind of music do you like?

Sonny: I like pop punk, like some emo music.

CJ: What are your favorite TV shows?

Sonny: I just watched Attack on Titan and it’s so good!

CJ: What’s your favorite food?

Sonny: Probably strawberries.

CJ: What’s the wildest or kinkiest thing you’ve ever done in your personal life?

Sonny: I had sex in a Catholic Church one time. I was with a boyfriend of mine and we were going on a trip. We saw that this church had construction going on outside of it and the doors were open. There were people on the outside and we snuck in the back. I had always wanted to have sex in a church and we went up to the balcony. We had sex and I was staring at the crucifix and I was having a panic attack and it was terrifying! And then we tried to sneak back out the way we came and the priest was there and he said, ‘You kids should know better than breaking into a place when you weren’t invited!’ I said, ‘We’re really sorry! We just wanted to see God today!’ It was a whole thing! (laughs)

CJ: And how can the fans follow you on social media?

Sonny: On Twitter, I’m @sonny_mckinley. Instagram is @alwayssonnymckinley. OnlyFans is alwayssonnymckinley.


Sonny McKinley


Sonny McKinley Movies, Photos, Talk

Pornstars, set up an interview with Captain Jack – message him through any of his forum posts (envelope icon,) or hit him up on Twitter.

1 Comment
  1. Man, I love this girl to death.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.